Please visit http://guntherportfolio.com
for new posts.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Solar Light Flashes: November 15, 2007

Select Photovoltaic News Tidbits

The Solar Light Flashes format allows me to address news or observations that don’t require a full post.

Cool Earth Solar
Cool Earth Solar (CES, http://www.coolearthsolar.com) has revamped their website and is reshaping solar energy. I heard from CEO Rob Lamkin that CES Senior Team member, Dr. Aurelius Prochazka, co-author of RailsSpace: Building a Social Networking Website with Ruby on Rails, was involved with the implementation. Back on August 24, 2007, the press release, COOL EARTH SOLAR FILES PATENTS FOR SOLAR TECHNOLOGY, demonstrates CSE efforts to protect their Intellectual Property (IP). And Cool Earth Solar in the News was nice enough to link to my post, Cool Earth Solar emerges from Stealth Mode.

GreenVolts Inc.
On Tuesday, November 27, 2007, Kevin Fine, Director of Product Development, GreenVolts, will present Solar Energy Technologies: Emphasis on Concentrating Photovoltaic Technologies, at the California PUC (CPUC) Building, Golden Gate Room, 505 Van Ness Ave., San Francisco, California USA, from Noon - 1:00 PM PST (Pacific Standard Time). This event is sponsored by the San Francisco Power Engineering Chapter of the IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.). Non-member cost and RSVP details are here.

RenewableEnergyAccess.com
As the Photovoltaic Blogger, reporting on the media is one of my easiest tasks. With rare exception, media never reports on the competition. While I jumped on the news of Intersolar North America 2008, RenewableEnergyAccess.com chose not to report on this significant new event but passed on this Industry Press Release, Record Early Sales of Solar Power 2008 Reflects Growth Trajectory of U.S. Solar Industry, post haste. Could it be because Solar Power 2008 is an advertiser and Media Partner?

RSI Silicon
I noticed RSI (Reaction Sciences Inc.) Silicon Products won the ICE 2007 Ignite Clean Energy Business Presentation Competition during my research into Wakonda Technologies. Per the RSI Silicon website:

Dr. Steve Amendola, along with his experienced team, has commenced building the first plant. It is envisaged that production at the 5,000 metric tonne per annum plant based in Northampton County, Pennsylvania, will commence Q2 2008.

Also notable here is:

RSI will be using low cost raw materials for processing solar grade silicon and not the Metallurgical Grade Si

even though Northampton is in rust belt steel country. I can only presume they will use a precursor with Silicon as a component unless they have developed a Silicon Replicator technology?

Here is the RSI Silicon ICE 2007 PowerPoint presentation and top Ten Finalist video by Newfangler Productions.

SunPower Corporation
On October 22, 2007, SunPower announced SunPower Names Brad Davis as Chief Marketing Officer. Towards the end of this press release, SunPower CEO Tom Werner said:

I am also pleased to announce that Peter Aschenbrenner will be assuming a new role as vice president, corporate strategy, continued Werner. In this position Peter will have responsibility for strategy, business development, and management of SunPower's product portfolio. Peter has been the primary architect of SunPower's strategy since 2003, and with three decades of solar industry experience he is uniquely qualified to help us capitalize on emerging global opportunities.

To date, I have not seen an official resolution of Peter Aschenbrenner under SEC investigation in AstroPower Saga. Could this move be a second step towards a quiet exit for Mr. Aschenbrenner from SunPower?

8. Forum Solarpraxis
I am looking forward to covering this Solarpraxis AG (FRA:SPA) event again next week on November 22-23, 2007, in Berlin, Germany. Here is the program (Deutsch). I am keen to checkout and report on this presentation:

International Solar Silicon Production – an Overview
John R. Mott, COO of Solarvalue Proizvodnja d.d., Ruse (Slovenia)

on Friday, November 23, 2007, at 14:30. I have requested access to select closed Analyst Conferences in advance to avoid a repeat of SOLON AG CEO Kicks PV Blogger Out of Analyst Conference. SOLON is not on my list.

Try entering the URL http://www.guntherportfolio.com and see where it takes you. I wonder what purpose this could serve?

Labels: , , , , , ,

Sunday, December 03, 2006

Summer Solar Rebate freeze highlights November 2006 NJCEP CORE Queues

NJCEP downplays summer freeze of solar rebates with success press release

If you read the recent press release from the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities (NJBPU), NEW JERSEY HIGHLIGHTS SUCCESS OF SOLAR MARKET, you might believe New Jersey’s Clean Energy Program™ (NJCEP, http://www.njcep.com) was a model of flawless execution in 2006. Likewise, the above chart of New Jersey Solar Installation Projects (CORE) by Quarter shows a slight drop in projects but an increase in Total kWp system capacity installed this summer 2006.

Actual NJCEP reality is reflected in the article, The Price of Success: Inside the NJ Clean Energy Program, by Stephen Lacey on RenewableEnergyAccess.com.

The Date of Approval Letter field in the latest CORE Queue <= 10kw Nov 22, 2006, shows no solar rebate applications were approved or checks issued from June 15, 2006, until September 29, 2006. The approvals for Q3/2006 were back end loaded to the absolute last business day of September 2006. The CORE Queue Less Than 10kWp has more than doubled since May 2006, but just over one third of the backlog has been addressed. Although the Date of Approval Letter field is not included in the CORE Queue Greater than 10kWp, any recent approvals occurred after the last CORE Queue release on September 15, 2006.

Talking with solar system installers and integrators at Solar Power 2006, I heard some scuttlebutt that the NJCEP program was being audited during the rebate freeze, allegedly because of “Pay to Play” concerns that have permeated New Jersey politics. I can only wonder what prompted the NJCEP to worry about New Jersey solar module shrinkage as reported in Gossip and Rumors from Solar Power 2006. Has there been a black market in rebated New Jersey solar modules?

I think NJCEP has done great work to promote solar and renewable energy in New Jersey, but they shouldn’t gloss over sustainable program growth issues with a press release.

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

Photovoltaic Market Situation - Must Read RE INSIDER Column





Price Decrease and Consolidation: The Solar PV Supply Chain

In this week’s RE INSIDER Column on RenewableEnergyAccess.com,
Edwin Koot, Founder and CEO of SolarPlaza.com, has written a pragmatic article about the current state of the PV Industry, Price Decrease and Consolidation: The Solar PV Supply Chain.

Mr. Koot has more original PV market articles on the SolarPlaza site well worth reading:
Spanish market in need of permits
PV in Italy: sunny future but slow and chaotic start (also on REA)

I am pleased to see some confirmation of my own observations in the following posts:
7. Forum Solarpraxis
German Market for Solar Modules soft
3rd PV Industry Forum at the EU PVSEC: Cost, Cost, Cost and Price / Politics (pro version on REA)

I heard Suntech Power Holdings Co., Ltd. (NYSE:STP) talked about lowering solar module prices by 5% in their Third Quarter 2006 Conference Call (I haven’t listened to it myself yet). This confirms my intuition that Suntech Power was lowering solar module prices in the US while other solar module manufacturers were raising prices in October 2006. I think Suntech Power is looking to gain market share and maintain lean inventories in a market with increasing solar module supply and tempered demand growth.

I was surprised to read how optimistic Jesse W. Pichel, Sr. Research Analyst, PiperJaffray (Piper Jaffray Companies, NYSE:PJC), was about the PV industry in his November 22, 2006 Industry Note, German Update From Solarpraxis; Solar Demand Stronger Than Anticipated.

GP Note: I could not find a link to Suntech Power’s Third Quarter 2006 Conference Call webcast in the Investor Relations section of their website, and I sent a request to their Investor Relations Team.

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

Blunden’s Blunder at EPIA’s 4th European PV Industry Forum

Has SunPower lost touch with California Residential Solar Installers?

Last year, it took almost a week for me to gather my thoughts and write an article worthy of publishing on RenewableEnergyAccess.com about the 3rd PV Industry Forum. It doesn’t take more than a few moments to realize when incorrect marketing spin is promoted in a public forum.

That was the case early today, September 5, 2007, at the 4th European PV Industry Forum held during the 22nd EU PVSEC in Milan, Italy. Julie Blunden, Vice President, Public Policy and Corporate Communications, SunPower Corporation (NASDAQ:SPWR), professed that the California solar market has developed well over the past two years. I only wish this were so for local solar installers in the residential market. Please view this partial video clip and make up your own mind. I overheard panel members make incredulous comments about her views.

This contradicts reliable sources such as the recent OPEN FORUM - The future is just overhead, this Blog (California Solar Initiative: No solar home installations “completed” yet in 2007), CSI: Examining California's Ambitious Solar Program, and Solar for Energy Hogs: The California Example.

My take away is SunPower is either motivated by politics to take this position or the large scale solar power plant business of their PowerLight subsidiary is robust in this environment. Regardless, this is bad news for SunPower’s installer channel partners.

And to think SunPower started the week with an informative and, for once, under hyped technical presentation, 2BP.1.2, titled “Low Cost, High Volume Production of >22% Efficiency Silicon Solar Cells” presented by (I think) Mr. De Ceuster.

Too bad. I would like to post something favorable about a company with the highest efficiency monocrystalline silicon solar cells in the world.

Thanks to the BITAGE| HOTSPOT for maintaining a FreeWiFi Hotspot at my Milano hangout, Bar Magenta. Ciao!

Labels: , ,

Monday, January 22, 2007

PV Technology, Performance, and Cost – 2006

New photovoltaic report co-authored by Paul Maycock, PV Energy Systems, and Travis Bradford, the Prometheus Institute for Sustainable Development

I received an email about the release of this report, PV Technology, Performance, and Cost – 2006, last week, although the report was first announced in a December 19, 2006, press release. Before searching, I had also not noticed this RenewableEnergyAccess.com IN FOCUS write up titled New Report Projects Future for the Global PV Market.

The PV Technology, Performance, and Cost – 2006 report features over 50 pages and 42 figures with chapters covering:
  • World PV Market Conditions Through 2005
  • Cell and Module Technology
  • Crystalline Silicon Ingots, Cells, and Modules
  • Other Current PV Technologies
  • Conclusions: PV Technology/Cost Summary
A sample figure was included in the email projecting:
manufacturing costs and profitability for current and emerging technologies through 2015.
At the price of $1200, the report’s appeal is limited to PV industry insiders, trade groups, investment analysts, governments, and think tanks. Be aware that only one half of the report price benefits the Prometheus Institute, a registered 501(c)3 non-profit organization.

If you prefer to try before you buy, the Tables of Contents and Figures from the report can be perused here. Inside Greentech has an interview with Mr. Bradford (I assume all references to Beckford are in fact Bradford?), Watch for falling solar margins, says report, by Dallas Kachan.

In a prior Blog post, DEAL! Solarvalue AG purchase receives final approval, I recommended reading the free report, Polysilicon: Supply, Demand & Implications for the PV Industry (free registration required for download), from The Prometheus Institute for Sustainable Development. I welcome a chance to write an independent review of the report, and I promise not to give the conclusions or ending away but provide a cost benefit assessment. I wonder if the Prometheus Institute folks will be interested in this proposal?

Friday, October 13, 2006

GUNTHER Portfolio debuts on Top50-Solar®



Initial rank 96 on Top50-Solar English version and climbing

Top50-Solar® (http://www.top50-solar.de) is an activity driven web catalog ranking registered solar and renewable energy websites based on their average number of visitors over the past 5 days. German, English, Spanish, and Portuguese websites are tracked and ranked in separate lists. Internationalized websites appear to be traffic ranked on a cumulative basis across their supported languages.

The Top50-Solar® was founded by Martin Staffhorst in July 2000 to provide objective and reliable traffic rankings of solar websites. Mr. Staffhorst has a Masters degree in Industrial Engineering (Dipl.-Wi.-Ing.) and is now working on his PhD.

Top50-Solar first tracked German solar websites and ranks 600 unique German language websites today including manufacturers, installers, e-stores, magazines, consultants, and organizations. SolarWorld AG (FRA:SWV) is ranked number three (3) on the Top50-Solar German list. PHOTON’s German website, PHOTON das Solarstrom-Magazin online, and English website, PHOTON International, are notably absent from the Top50-Solar rankings.

While Top50-Solar has a strong presence among German solar and renewable energy websites, Mr. Staffhorst is looking to expand the Top50-Solar’s global reach and expects the English version to rival the German version in the future.

I recommend the two top US solar and renewable energy websites, SolarBuzz and RenewableEnergyAccess.com, join the Top50-Solar web catalog. Both sites would debut at the top of the rankings. Photovoltaic companies such as Evergreen Solar Inc. (NASDAQ:ESLR), First Solar LLC, and SunPower Corporation (NASDAQ:SPWR) would also benefit from listing with Top50-Solar.

Smaller solar and renewable websites and blogs will gain traffic and international exposure by registering with Top50-Solar. Put on your marketing hat and register right away.

Monday, October 02, 2006

GE Solar Technologies: Molded Wafer technology investments continue

Silicon-Film(TM) - By any other name.

I have confirmed GE Solar Technologies is still working on the renamed Molded Wafer technology. But GE Solar would not disclose Molded Wafer production capacity or any expansion plans. GE Solar Technologies is a part of the Renewables unit of GE Energy, which belongs to GE Infrastructure, a primary business unit of General Electric Company (NYSE:GE).

Here is a link to a recent, public PHOTON International article where they have the facts but nothing on the name change from Silicon-Film to Molded Wafer.

Armed with the new name, I was able to find a presentation, Overview of Solar Photovoltaic Markets and Technology, from Charles Korman, Chief Technologist, Solar Energy, GE Global Research Center (GRC). This was presented on March 28, 2006, as Lecture 9 to the MSE 542 Flexible Electronics class at Cornell University and provides a thoughtful overview of PV technology. There is one slide on Molded Silicon Wafer with no new information, but the presentation tips GRC interest in Nanostructured Solar Cells, Fluorescent Concentrator, Bifacial sliver solar cells, and PV Building Integrated Technology. On the Building Integrated Photovoltaic (BIPV) front, the presentation cites the Solar Integrated Technologies, Inc. (SEA:SIT) SR2001 Solar Electric Roofing System as an example of flexible roofing.

I also found this 2006 Senior Design Sponsor Project Description at the University of Delaware, Department of Mechanical Engineering. GE Energy is the sponsor of this Wafer Inspection Tool project: Develop an inspection tool for mapping thickness, warp, taper and flatness variations of molded polycrystalline silicon wafers used in photovoltaic solar cells.

There are now photovoltaic posts at the GE Global Research Blog, From Edison's Desk: Shining Light on Alternative Energy Technologies at Edison's Desk and Update from Wired NextFest as part of GE’s presenting sponsor participation at WIRED NextFest 2006.

Back on June 21, 2006, GE Solar introduced the Brilliance™ All-In-One Residential Solar System Package sized from 1kWp (1,000 Watt peak) to 10kWp with new BIPV 66Wp solar modules for roof-integrated new home construction or 200Wp solar modules for retrofit applications.

By the way, GE Solar is hiring. Check the Renewable Energy Jobs at RenewableEnergyAccess.com for example.

Monday, September 18, 2006

3rd PV Industry Forum at the EU PVSEC: Cost, Cost, Cost and Price / Politics

Please see Renewable Energy Access (http://www.renewableenergyaccess.com/rea/news/reinsider/story?id=45990 ) for the final, professional version of this article. Here is the extended version.


Reflecting on the 21st European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition (EU PVSEC) in Dresden, Germany, the 3rd PV Industry Forum, New Strategies for the Booming PV Market, was the major event upstaging the technical conference presentations on Wednesday, September 6, 2006. PV industry insider views diverged on worldwide PV market growth with forecasts ranging from 5.5GW (GigaWatts) to 11GW of annual installation capacity by 2010 from about 1.4GW in 2005. This divergence on PV market growth was driven by continued concerns about silicon feedstock supplies and PV industry reliance on political renewable energy policy incentives and subsidy programs.

The European Photovoltaic Industry Association (EPIA) established the PV Industry Forum as a platform to discuss industry related issues. PV Industry and Political/Strategic view points were presented on key topics such as PV Market Development and Industry Competitiveness. Each theme was chaired by industry leaders, and a moderated debate on the viewpoints with attendee participation was facilitated by Ranga Yogeshwar, WDR, Radio & TV, Germany.

Dr. Winfried Hoffmann, President of EPIA and general manager of SCHOTT Solar GmbH, reviewed the state of the PV industry and provided the conservative EPIA PV market forecast of 5.5GW by 2010 and another 5-10 years to reach grid price parity in sun rich Southern Europe.

On the silicon feedstock front, Dr. Hubert Aulich, CEO of PV Silicon AG, analyzed silicon feedstock availability for photovoltaic and semiconductor industries until 2010 and concluded an additional 35,000 metric tons of silicon feedstock production capacity, beyond all the recent announcements, is required to fuel 35% annual PV market growth.

Cost, Cost, Cost was the mantra of German PV market leaders Q-Cells (FRA:QCE) and Deutsche Solar (a subsidiary of SolarWorld (FRA:SWV) ). Both companies recognize the importance of driving down costs for crystalline silicon technologies to achieve grid electricity rate parity and position the PV industry for long term growth.

Deutsche Solar COO Boris Klebensberger said, “It’s not a question of growth – it’s a question of COST!” Deutsche Solar forecasts a worldwide PV market of 10GW by 2010: 8GW for crystalline silicon products and a possible 2GW for thin films with the refrain “Now or Never”. Mr. Klebensberger predicted increasing economies of scale as PV factories evolve from 100MWp production today to 250MWp and even 1GWp by 2010 and beyond as Big Players dominate the industry.

Q-Cells AG co-founder and CEO Anton Milner also emphasized the rapid cost reduction of photovoltaics to lower the Euros (€) per Watt cost. Mr. Milner believes the supply side will correct in 2008-9 as more silicon feedstock becomes available to close the demand gap, but the underlying demand in 2010 is unclear with 80 to 90% of PV installations dependent on government feed-in tariffs or subsidies. However, Mr. Milner thought the PV market in 2010 could be as large as 11GW! Mr. Milner said multicrystalline silicon (mc-Si) has the potential for cost reductions of 40-50%, and thin film technologies such as CSG Solar’s microcrystalline silicon will not become mainstream before 2010. Looking beyond the silicon situation, Mr. Milner believes educated and trained people will become a medium and long term bottleneck for PV industry growth.

In response to a question about lower solar module prices in 2007, Mr. Klebensberger said, “No Idea, but most probably. Prices are made by the Market and nothing else.” Dr. Karin Freier, German Federal Ministry for the Environment, expressed concerns regarding Mr. Klebensberger’s glib statement underscoring the fragile relationship between PV companies and politicians. While Germany is committed to renewable energy sources for electricity generation and is investing in renewable industries as a growth and job creation engine, politicians may become fickle about high PV industry margins and profits and consider accelerating the feed-In tariff digression to jostle the PV industry on pricing.

Given EPIA’s track record of underestimating PV market growth, I give the forecast edge to a 10GW market by 2010 if there is sufficient silicon, favorable renewable energy policies, and 40% cost reductions resulting in lower solar module pricing. I believe the PV industry is poised to continue fast growth but not at a constant rate; there will be periods of greater than trend growth and slower periods of supply correction to match demand. I expect sharp, downward price corrections at the module level in the 2008-9 timeframe as idle cell, wafer, and module capacity and new production facilities are supplied with new silicon feedstock. Contract silicon pricing and increasing economies of scale will return the PV industry to the historical cost curve making up for lost time between 2005 and 2007.