Please visit http://guntherportfolio.com
for new posts.

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Schmid Silicon Technology: Polysilicon Update

Silicon strategy covers the gamut of quartz and metallurgical silicon to polysilicon.

There has been a dearth of news regarding Schmid Silicon Technology (SST) since the Sunways AG enters polysilicon production business announcement and my Schmid Silicon Technology: From East Germany with Polysilicon post.

At PHOTON’s 6th Solar Silicon Conference on April 1, 2008, part of the Photovoltaic Technology Show 2008 Europe, Gebr. Schmid GmbH + Co. (Deutsch) representatives, Frank Tinnefeld and Jochem Hahn, presented “From sand to module – a fully vertical integrated approach for the PV Industry.”

Schmid has observed the Euro price of silicon metal has increased almost fifty percent since 2005. As a result, Schmid has formed a joint venture in Kazakhstan, Schmid Silicon Kazakhstan, to mine quartz (SiO2), not sand, and to build and operate a metallurgical silicon (mg-Si) production facility. In the first phase, Schmid plans (“investments will be explored”) to invest about USD $150 Million to construct a facility with 30,000 metric tons per year of mg-Si production capacity:

  • 10,000 metric tons per year of mg-Si will be processed by Schmid Silicon Technology into 6,000 metric tons per year of Polysilicon
  • 20,000 metric tons per year of mg-Si will be sold on the world market

Having secured land and mining rights at a location northeast of Taraz, Kazakhstan, construction of the mg-Si facility will start in July 2008, and silicon metal production is slated to start in the second half of 2009.

Schmid believes they have developed a new way to produce polysilicon using the UMOSI process:

single step catalytic disproportion of chlor silane mixture to monosilane and pyrolysis of monosilane:
4 HSiCl3 = 3 SiCl4 + SiH4; SiH4 = Si + 2 H2
Optimized total process structure in respect to:
Hydrochlorination, Hydration, Disproportion and Pyrolysis

SST claims the UMOSI process produces polysilicon with a cumulative cost structure 28% cheaper than the Siemens process. SST has partnered with Spectrum for “Monosilan Technology and Process Know-How” forming a joint venture called (I presume) Schmid Silicon Ukraine (SSU). And yet another joint venture, Schmid Silicon Engineering (SSE) has been formed with an unnamed EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) firm for engineering and chemical plant construction.

SST plans to construct pilot production, TCS (Trichlorosilane, HSiCl3), and 6,000 metric ton (6 x 1000 metric tons) production facilities at the Schwarze Pumpe Industrial Park (Industriepark) located between Spremberg and Spreewitz, Germany. Per the SST schedule, the first 2,000 metric ton production facility will begin construction in the third quarter of 2008 and be commissioned in the fourth quarter of 2009.

SST is still looking for additional investors in the 6,000 metric ton polysilicon fab (Silicon Fab “Schwarze Pumpe”) project in 1,000 metric ton modular clusters. SST touts silicon independence, scalability, cost savings at 6,000 metric ton scale, a 3 to 5 year return on investment (ROI), and “highly innovative technology and equipment with high potential for future development” as key investment drivers.

To date, Sunways AG (FRA:SWW) has been the only investor named in the SST project. In the Sunways investor Presentation Feb. 2008 on slide 19, Sunways notes Schmid is responsible for the “construction, installation and utilities operation of a turnkey plant for the production of 1,000 tons solar silicon as of 2010”. This arrangement appears to be a corollary to the Foundry/Fabless joint venture business models that evolved in the semiconductor industry. Will Schmid Silicon Technology operate these turnkey polysilicon plants for their customers or expect them to take the keys and drive as with Schmid’s turnkey production equipment solutions for solar wafers, cells, and modules? I believe many solar companies will find a “Fabless” polysilicon business model with guaranteed capacity at industry competitive costs attractive.

And in 1366 Technologies Wins Solar Startup Competition, Ucilia Wang at Greentech Media reports that GreenVolts CEO Bob Cart "announced it is bidding for a 26-megawatt project that would ramp up to a capacity of 1,000 megawatts per year by 2015." I wonder if this was the mysterious project mentioned in my post, GreenVolts at BIG Solar?

Labels: , ,

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Solarvalue AG Analyst Conference at the 8. Forum Solarpraxis

[Berlin, Germany]

Sample me this? Production risks are back end loaded.
Sunways CEO Roland Burkhardt’s take on Solarvalue.

First, let’s cover what went well at the Solarvalue AG (XETRA:SV7) Analyst Conference. As you can see in the above photo, the conference had good analyst attendance including man about solar Jesse Pichel, Vice President and Sr. Research Analyst, PiperJaffray. Maximillian Fischer, Solarvalue Investor Relations, provided a short overview and was followed by Solarvalue CTO (Chief Technology Officer) Dr. Julio Bragagnolo. Alas, from here things did not always go up and to the right.

Solar Grade Silicon (SGS) lab samples

Solarvalue should deliver SGS lab sample material on the order of 10’s of kilograms before year end. The SGS sample material will be from a US lab not Ruše. The same physical process is used to make the sample material but it is not identical to the production process flow.

About 250 kilograms of SGS are required to cast a typical multicrystalline silicon (mc-Si) ingot, so 10’s of kilograms of material are insufficient for verification on existing production lines using customer manufacturing process flows. Way back in Secretive solar start-up, Solarvalue AG, reveals solar grade silicon production plans through joint venture bid for TDR-Metalurgija in Ruse, Slovenia, I said:

Solarvalue will need to develop a stable process and deliver sample production SGS material to solar wafer and cell partners for qualification.

These lab samples are preproduction and only an indication of what is possible in production. One analyst asked the key question. How do you know this process will scale in production?

Cross Examination on SGS Material Impurities

Following the presentation, Research Analysts asked Dr. Bragagnolo probing questions about the quality of the SGS material, its usefulness for making solar cells, and the process. Dr. Bragagnolo engaged with the Research Analysts in a round-robin discussion of one-upsmanship regarding the impurity levels in the Solarvalue SGS material.

Mr. Pichel triggered this exchange by citing information about Timminco having 5ppm (parts per million) Boron (B) and Phosphorus (P) impurity levels or better in their Solar Grade Silicon.

First Dr. Bragagnolo clarified the high quality silicon metal (metallurgical silicon) from the arc furnace would have below 1ppm of Boron and Phosphorus and sub 5ppm of other impurities. When pressed if this level of Boron could be used to make a working silicon solar cell, Dr. Bragagnolo claimed the SGS impurity target for Boron was under 1ppm or 0.1ppm.

However, in supporting these targets, Dr. Bragagnolo cited the old work at Solarex and did not have or present Solarvalue lab analysis data for even the lab sample material and admitted Solarvalue has not fully tested the silicon made with the process. In essence, Solarvalue has performed a book calculation regarding material made with their process to date.

Production Equipment Status

Solarvalue is working with a US engineering firm to translate their process and plant concept into the detailed engineering of a number of production components that will be assembled in Ruše, Slovenia. In reviewing the process flow, an iterative collaboration between Solarvalue and their engineering partner has resulted in improving the process to 30% material conversion efficiency from metallurgical silicon (mg-Si) to SGS albeit slipping the engineering schedule.

Lab samples aside, Solarvalue’s approach of going straight to production and bypassing a pilot line results in the process being developed and fine tuned on the production line. Any process issues discovered at this point will be more expensive to correct, resulting in further production start up delays, and idle capital production assets.

If it is Thursday, it must be M1

M1 is the arc furnace being retrofit for metallurgical silicon (mg-Si) production. No schedule was provided. Solarvalue has changed plans from the M5 arc furnace to M6 and now to M1. These changes are related to Solarvalue’s challenging relationship with W&P Profil CEO Alojz Cajnko who now controls M5 and M6. M1 is the largest yet oldest of the three arc furnaces. I also believe it will be more difficult to convert to silicon metal production than M6. No wonder Solarvalue will start production with purchased silicon metal.

As a result, Solarvalue has lost the strategic benefit of using their arc furnace to produce high quality silicon metal for initial SGS production. Analysts were concerned about the old furnace equipment introducing contaminants into the silicon metal. Knowing John Mott, I believe the Solarvalue team will handle this issue during the retrofit.

Sunways

At the Sunways AG (FRA:SWW) Analyst Conference, an analyst asked CEO Roland Burkhardt about Sunways’ reasons for partnering with Solarvalue and questioned Solarvalue’s competence in silicon production as his take away from the Solarvalue Analyst Conference the previous day.

Translating and paraphrasing Mr. Burkhardt’s response, he visited Slovenia to verify the existence of the arc furnace. It did indeed exist, and he left convinced Solarvalue has the people and expertise to make metallurgical silicon. Whether Solarvalue could produce usable (for solar cells) Solar Grade Silicon via their refinement process was an open question. He summarized by saying the concept was possible given the Solarvalue team’s related experience in particular with a similar process at Solarex. Concluding, Mr. Burkhardt said, We’ll believe it when we see it.

From the Sunways perspective, the Solarvalue relationship (Solarvalue and Sunways to cooperate on solar cell development) is an inexpensive call option on Solarvalue’s ability to deliver Solar Grade Silicon useable for mc-Si solar cells.

There was much more analyst interest in the Sunways LDK deal (Sunways Reactor-Wafer reversal deal with LDK Solar). And Monday’s announcement, Sunways AG enters polysilicon production business (Deutsch), indicates Sunways is developing a portfolio approach to silicon sourcing.

Additional Solarvalue Points

  • The Solarvalue process is targeting 20% initial yield of SGS from mg-Si inputs and expects to improve the yield to 30% although no timeframe was given. The balance of silicon is sold as commodity mg-Si.
  • Solarvalue claims they will have about 2400 metric tons (at 20% yield) of SGS production capacity in place by the end of 2008 and produce less than 1000 metric tons of SGS in 2008. It stuck me the SGS produced in 2008 is very similar to the numbers discussed last year in Solarvalue discusses plans and process representing a one year delay.
  • The final casting of multicrystalline silicon (mc-Si) ingots by the solar wafer customer is the last step of the process.
  • Even though Solarvalue will use hydroelectric power from a nearby power plant, the electricity cost is not low since Slovenia net imports electricity to meet demand.
  • Capex (capital expenditures) was pegged at less than €50 Million.
  • No pro forma financials were presented.

While they may have been honest and forthright, Dr. Bragagnolo made a number of statements that were unsettling in their delivery. For example, Dr. Bragagnolo said:

The process will work, what is unknown and constitutes a risk is when it will work.
It’s a time issue. There’s always risk - that’s life.

Here is the Solarvalue presentation from the Analyst Conference at the 8. Forum Solarpraxis.

In Solar Light Flashes: November 15, 2007, I said I would cover:

International Solar Silicon Production – an Overview
John R. Mott, COO of Solarvalue Proizvodnja d.d., Ruse (Slovenia)

Dr. Bragagnolo substituted for Mr. Mott. I missed the later panel discussions so I may not be writing a post about this.

I don’t expect any Research Analysts to initiate coverage of Solarvalue as a result of this Analyst Conference.

GP Note: In case there was any question after the post, Solarvalue AG: Why has the stock declined?, I do not own any shares of Solarvalue AG stock and have never traded them.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 05, 2007

Solarvalue and Sunways to cooperate on solar cell development

Aim to produce marketable solar cells from solar grade silicon

With many years of accumulated expertise in monocrystalline and multicrystalline silicon solar cell development and processing, Sunways AG (FRA:SWW) is a stronger research and development partner for Solarvalue AG (XETRA:SV7) than Moser Baer Photo Voltaic Limited (MBPV). MBPV is focused on bringing up turnkey silicon solar cell production lines at the current time.

Here are the dueling company press releases: Sunways and Solarvalue enter into cooperation agreement for the production and processing of solar silicon (Deutsch) or Cooperation between Solarvalue and Sunways (Deutsch).

Sunways said the following:

If the development cooperation can be successfully implemented, both partners will enter into a supply contract.

Since both Sunways and Solarvalue are synergistic companies without overlap, a successful cooperation could lead to even closer ties. Sunways is involved with every step of the solar value chain besides silicon production after Sunways Reactor-Wafer reversal deal with LDK Solar. Almost a year ago, Sunways was on the short list of companies rumored to be interested in investing in Solarvalue.

Check out this Interview with John R. Mott, COO of Solarvalue Proizvodnja d.d., on the status of development in Ruse (Deutsch) on the Solarvalue home page. There is scarce new information here, but the verb tense (see bold I added to the text) of this section is interesting:

We will be producing solar grade silicon samples within the next few weeks. Afterwards, the final fine tuning of the production process will be carried out. Production will then start up within the first half of 2008. This gradual “ramp- up” will minimize risk and keep the rejection quota low. We intend to produce several thousand metric tons of high-purity solar grade silicon in 2008.

Labels: ,

Monday, September 24, 2007

Sunways Reactor-Wafer reversal deal with LDK Solar

Sunways parlays two Siemens Reactors into 10 year, 1GW wafer contract

Continuing to go its very own way, Sunways AG (FRA:SWW) has reversed course and leveraged the two:

Siemens-reactors and associated equipment for a polysilicon production plant including substantial support services

into a multicrystalline silicon solar wafer contract with LDK Solar Co., Ltd. (NYSE:LDK). Wafer deliveries for the total 1GW (Giga-Watt) contract are set to begin in 2008 and cover a period of ten years. See Sunways AG: Strategic agreement for raw material supply with LDK Solar Co., Ltd. signed for the official press release.

With polysilicon still in tight supply, it is no surprise that polysilicon production equipment and consulting services are also oversubscribed. Did CEO Roland Burkhardt always plan to flip his nascent silicon plant or was this deal brokered by key services partner, SolMic GmbH? For LDK Solar, this was a straightforward time to market issue. I speculate (unconfirmed at post time) Sunways’ option to buy five additional reactors is part of this deal.

No contract terms and conditions were disclosed but the following was mentioned: Down-payments have been agreed specifically according to the overall project volume.

I have to feel I was hood winked a bit by a fox on this one. Or did Herr Burkhardt take my advice and decide to look for trichlorosilane (TCS) and a plant location outside of Germany to the extreme of going to China?

Labels: , ,

Monday, August 13, 2007

Sunways goes its own Silicon ways – Part 2

Interview with CEO Roland Burkhardt at Intersolar 2007

In Sunways goes its own Silicon ways – Part 1, I examined the basic facts regarding Sunways’ entry into polysilicon production. While trichlorosilane (TCS) sourcing and co-location may seem like the biggest challenges facing Sunways AG (FRA:SWW), obtaining expertise to design, construct, and operate their polysilicon deposition production facility is the single most critical factor to success.

Thus far, Sunways has disclosed SolMic GmbH as a lone firm among other suppliers. Who is SolMic and why is it straight forward to conclude SolMic is the primary consulting firm to Sunways on this project?

SolMic was founded by Dr. Albrecht Mozer and Dr. Peter Fath in 2005

to offer various consulting and engineering services related to photovoltaics and microelectronics industry with a special focus on polysilicon production facilities

after Dr. Mozer was removed on November 5, 2004, from the executive management of Siltronic AG (Siltronic stärkt Marktausrichtung auf 300 mm Wafer), a Wacker Chemie AG (FRA:WCH) subsidiary, under the pretext of focusing corporate strategy on 300mm semiconductor wafers.

SolMic is in turn a 50% subsidiary of GP Solar GmbH, a company Dr. Fath cofounded in 1999 for solar cell processing and characterization consulting and technology transfer. GP Solar partnered with system manufacturer Centrotherm to commercialize solar cell processing technologies developed by the PV (Photovoltaic) research team at the University of Konstanz. GP Solar has consulting References with a Who’s Who list of photovoltaic companies in Germany, Europe, and around the world including Sunways.

So what are SolMic’s polysilicon project credentials to date?

In this PHOTON EXPO 4th Solar Silicon Conference abstract, Silicon factory planning based on Siemens reactors: Status and future challenges, SolMic claimed to have signed contracts to built 5000 metric tons per year of Siemens process polysilicon production capacity. In addition, SolMic has a consulting contract to build a MG-SoG (Metallurgical to Solar Grade) polysilicon plant per Scheuten Solar moves into own production of solar silicon. As a result, Scheuten SolarWorld Solizium GmbH is a joint venture formed between Scheuten Solar and SolarWorld AG to produce Solar Grade Silicon at a location in Freiberg, Germany, near the Deutsche Solar AG Business Unit SolarMaterial. A PHOTON International article reprint (PI 9/2006, p. 58-60 +61 missing?) about SolMic, Robin Hoods of PV, is available from the Scheuten website.

The next point concerns the formation of Centrotherm SiQ GmbH by SolMic and Centrotherm to produce Siemens process reactors and converters. Could Centrotherm be the supplier of these reactors to Sunways? I thought I had read about this connection somewhere, but this may be pure conjecture as I cannot find a corroborating source. If you want to learn more about polysilicon production equipment, the Poly Plant Project, Inc. has background information about Polysilicon Deposition Reactors and Thermal Converters.

Having explored the SolMic connection in digressive detail, Sunways’ strategy to purchase TCS simplifies their polysilicon project by lowering capital expenditures but adds risk in terms of steady supply and complicates the recycling of gas byproducts from the decomposition of TCS in the polysilicon deposition reactors. Recycling these gas byproducts is crucial to produce low cost polysilicon. Perhaps TCS recycling or the pilot scale 300 metric ton production capacity or both are contributing factors to the high estimate of polysilicon production costs below €45 per kilogram.

With SolMic, Sunways has the right technology partner to succeed at polysilicon production once the TCS sourcing and plant location issues are resolved. I admire Herr Burkhardt’s determination to enter polysilicon production in a staged manner without lining up every aspect of the project in advance.

But, I believe Sunways must plan for success and build their facility to accommodate 1000 metric tons of polysilicon production per year from the start with allowances for future expansion. Sunways should exercise the option on five more reactors to expand polysilicon production once the pilot process is proven. Although I am sure Herr Burkhardt is favoring plant locations in Germany with eastern Germany leading because of government incentives, I recommend he also consider sites outside of Germany, perhaps in southwestern or eastern Europe. A viable option outside of Germany is the best way to insure any German TCS negotiations are competitive.

Alas, the efforts of Sunways in the automotive space will have to wait for a follow up post.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

Sunways goes its own Silicon ways – Part 1

Interview with CEO Roland Burkhardt at Intersolar 2007

I wasn’t planning to visit Intersolar 2007 on Saturday, June 23, 2007, the last day of the tradeshow. Although I thought there would be throngs of consumers looking for home solar solutions, there was lighter foot traffic than the first two days. And, since the business meetings were almost complete, there was improved access to upper management at the individual companies.

As I stood at the Sunways AG (FRA:SWW) stand main desk waiting to ask questions about Sunways will be supplied with two reactors for the production of high-purity silicon (Deutsch), I noticed a gentleman from Sunways taking photos of the stand. I thought I recognized him from the 7. Forum Solarpraxis as Sunways CEO Roland Burkhardt. As it turns out, Herr Burkhardt took a photo of me (right front) at the main desk before I noticed him at the stand!

After introducing myself, I managed to establish my solar and polysilicon credentials to obtain Herr Burkhardt’s attention and coax the following quotes about Sunway’s silicon plans:

We want to develop a secured long-term procurement strategy of high-purity silicon with better terms than long period contracts with prepayment.

Wir wollen uns eine Absicherung von Reinstsilizium aufbauen, die uns besere Bedingungen bietet als Langfristverträge mit Prepayment.

The two Siemens process reactors will be ramped to 300 metric tons of electronic grade polysilicon production capacity per year by 2009. Sunways has partnered with SolMic GmbH and other suppliers to obtain all the required production equipment. Sunways is in discussions with three potential locations (partners) for essential trichlorosilane (TCS) supply and co-location of polysilicon production. Selection criteria beyond TCS include skilled employees, energy costs, and economic incentives.

The 300 metric tons of polysilicon capacity translates to about 30MWp (MegaWatts-peak) of monocrystalline or polycrystalline silicon solar cell production depending on silicon utilization in grams per Watt. Sunways produced 28MWp of solar cells in 2006. Sunways’ nominal solar cell production capacity is 30MWp in Arnstadt, Germany, for traditional modules and 16MWp in Constance, Germany, for automotive and architectural applications.

Given existing sources of wafer supply and recent deals (see Sunways AG enters into a contract on the supply of wafers with Deutsche Solar AG), Sunways decided to sign a long term polysilicon supply deal with an unnamed cooperation partner and received an up front payment of €10 million for future polysilicon shipments.

Alas, fair disclosure regulations and competitive considerations don’t allow even CEO’s to disclose new information on a selective basis. But in a report titled Own silicon production, equinet AG has compiled additional details and analysis perhaps with inputs from a conference call. Polysilicon production volumes are expected to reach about 200 metric tons in 2008 at a production cost below €45 per kilogram. equinet estimates capex (capital expenditures) totaling €20 million for the project, and Sunways has stated most of this investment will occur in 2007. equinet has helped underwrite securities for Sunways in the past.

I was able to confirm a report in Photon International (PI 6/2007, p. 50-51) with a Sunways spokesperson. Sunways does have an option to buy five additional reactors with the potential of expanding production capacity to about 1000 metric tons of polysilicon per year.

In Part 2, I will continue examining this polysilicon project and delve into Sunways’ automotive efforts.

Things have been quiet on the Blog this past week. Although my pipeline is overflowing, I had to drop everything because of family visiting the Bay for the last two weeks.

Labels: