Please visit http://guntherportfolio.com
for new posts.

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

What have you been missing at guntherportfolio.com?

And Holiday Greetings.

Since GUNTHER Portfolio launches guntherportfolio.com, I've contributed a lackluster though high quality thirteen (13) posts. This should improve as the new year approaches.

I didn't have the time or positive material for a Christmas Eve post, so I decided to wish email and RSS subscribers a Happy Holiday. Please see Best Wishes for the Holidays and a fine 2009! for my online greeting card.

I do wonder if photovoltaic industry analysts are too negative about 2009. If polysilicon is supposed to be in oversupply and solar module prices are projected to decline by 20-30%, shouldn't this spur additional demand because of price elasticity? In Germany, is there a better guaranteed investment than photovoltaic panels on one's home or business?

Per "Fachbücher als Geschenk" from the Märkische Allgemeine, Nanosolar GmbH donated books focused on solar technology to the Luckenwalde Public Library just before Christmas. Good Christmas Spirit deal!

Labels: ,

Sunday, September 21, 2008

Nanosolar: Photovoltaic Hindsight Insights? REVISED

Reviewing the efficiency calculation.

Building on my prior post, Nanosolar: Photovoltaic Hindsight Insights?, “Nanosolar to Build 10MW Power Plant” by Ucilia Wang at Greentech Media obtained feedback on the story from Nanosolar, Inc. Chief Executive Officer Martin Roscheisen:

Roscheisen also wrote that two technical details in the newspaper articles were wrong. The June article said the size of the glass plate for a finished panel measures at 2 square meters. Roscheisen wrote that Nanosolar's panel is "compatible with First Solar's, which are 1.6 x .8m in size."

Roscheisen added that the 7,000 panels reported for the 1-megawatt plant also was wrong, but didn't offer the correct number.

Well, Nanosolar partner Beck Energy GmbH has First Solar’s FS Series 2 Solar Module datasheet (Deutsch) on their website, and the First Solar module dimensions are in fact 1.2 x 0.6m (meters).

Looking at the Nanosolar module array photo shown in Nanosolar solar modules shipping!, the modules are arranged as five (5) by ten (10) CIGS (copper indium gallium diselenide) rectangular looking solar cells. I do not believe Nanosolar has ever stated the cell size; they appear to be about 6” (156mm) square in area terms? This rough sizing would confirm the 1.6 x 0.8m panel size.

Using the 1.6 x 0.8m panel size cited by Mr. Roscheisen and the calculated 142.9 Watts per module assuming the 7000 panels remains reasonable, the implied Nanosolar Utility Panel module efficiency becomes 11.16%.

First, do I need to point out the 142.9 Watts per module would be an average module efficiency for the entire 1 MWp (MegaWatt-peak) installation? Per Sorted-Cell Assembly, Nanosolar’s metal foil substrate cells can be tested, binned, and matched to increase module efficiency and yield much like crystalline silicon based solar cells. No doubt the unpublic Nanosolar Utility Panel module datasheet includes a range of power ratings. However, without Nanosolar cell or module production efficiency data in histogram form, it is impossible to determine if more or less than 7000 modules are required for the 1 MWp Luckenwalde landfill project as Mr. Roscheisen asserts. For example, if the average module efficiency is 12% (153.6 Wp, Watt-peak), about 6500 modules would be required for the 1MWp installation, while 10% average module efficiency (128 Wp) would require just over 7800 modules.

From the Nanosolar Wikipedia entry, I found this award winning article, “Solarzellen - einfach gedruckt” (“Solar cells – simply printed”, German only) by Johannes Bernreuter for bild der wissenschaft 2|2007, also referenced by the Nanosolar website. The article delves into the history of the nanoparticle CIGS printing technology and past efficiency, potential, and verified efficiency results. Please remember the “14.5% Cell Produced Using Low-Cost Printing Process” touted by Nanosolar was for a 0.47 square centimeter cell printed on a glass substrate. NREL (National Renewable Energy Laboratory) measured the cell’s efficiency at 13.95% in August 2006, and Nanosolar said:

NREL measured one of Nanosolar’s cells on glass at about 14% on a total-area basis, equivalent to about 14.5% on an active-area basis after correcting for shadowing by the grid (Voc = 599mV, Jsc = 32.2mA/cm2, FF = 72.3).

To our knowledge, this is the highest efficiency yet reported for any printed solar cell of any kind and any CIGS cells fabricated using non-vacuum methods in particular.

in the PVSEC-17 paper, “HIGH-PERFORMANCE THIN-FILM PHOTOVOLTAICS USING LOW-COST PROCESS TECHNOLOGY”.

I hesitate to share this. One of my favorite German restaurants near Luckenwalde, Landgasthof "Zum Märkischen Eck", is about a 20 minute drive from Nanosolar GmbH. It’s worth a visit; just make sure to save a table for my relatives and me!

Labels: ,

Sunday, September 14, 2008

Nanosolar: Photovoltaic Hindsight Insights?

10 MW (MegaWatt) solar power plant project proposed in the Rieselfelder near Luckenwalde.
Updates on the original 1 MW solar farm project imply 7.15% (not 14%, see GP Correction note) Module Efficiency.

Nanosolar, Inc. was back in the news late last month with the Nanosolar Blog post, “Nanosolar Ups Funding to $1/2B; Partners Strategically for Solar Utility Power”, regarding a March 2008 funding round. For coverage, please see “Nanosolar Confirms $300M Funding” by Jennifer Kho at Greentech Media or “Nanosolar Boosts Funds to Massive Half Billion Dollars” by Katie Fahrenbacher at Earth2Tech.

Although I have not posted about Nanosolar since the cancelled eBay auction, I managed to find dated yet uncirculated news about Nanosolar GmbH in the regional German newspaper, Märkische Allgemeine.

In April 2008, “ENERGIEPOLITIK: Viel Platz für die Sonne, Auf ehemaligen Luckenwalder Rieselfeldern soll ein großes Solarkraftwerk entstehen” (German only) by Elinor Wenke reported on the proposal to build a 10 MWp (MegaWatt-peak) solar power plant on 57 hectares (140.8 acres) at a cost of around €30 million or €3 per Watt. Beck Energy GmbH teamed with Nanosolar on the project located on the former Rieselfelder (please see My Google Map) in between the Berkenbrücker und Ruhlsdorfer Chaussee roads not far from the Nanosolar GmbH factory.

Beck Energy’s Bernhard Beck would like to complete the project over the next year and said the 10MW photovoltaic plant can power 10000 residential homes with electricity each year. Echoing the Nanosolar Blog post, “Municipal Solar Power Plants”, released about the same time, Mr. Beck emphasized the benign nature of the plant on the environment. Grass can grow under and around the ground based solar arrays, and though large animals will be fenced out, smaller animals can live in harmony with the installation. However, the land cannot be used for agriculture and is owned by NUWAB (municipal water and sewage company) and the town of Luckenwalde combined with leased parcels. The land usage appears inefficient versus the Nanosolar metric of 10 acres per 2 MW. Perhaps land utilization is limited by existing uses or there are plans for future expansion?

Per “ENERGIEPOLITIK: 30 Millionen Euro für Solarkraftwerk”, the Luckenwalde business and planning boards voted unanimously to approve the submission of a development plan for the project and to change the land’s zoning. Not surprising since the Luckenwalde town government helped Beck Energy and Nanosolar select the location for the solar power plant.

So what about the 1 MWp reference solar farm project located at the retired landfill in Luckenwalde, Germany, I first posted about “In Search of Nanosolar GmbH”?

From May 2008, “WIRTSCHAFT: Sonnenschein über der Deponie, Am Frankenfelder Berg in Luckenwalde entsteht bis Ende November 2008 ein Solarpark” by Uta Franke reported on the laying of a ceremonial foundation stone with a time capsule and commemoration plaque for the 1 MW solar park on a sunny day in Luckenwalde. The solar park will cover 1.9 Hectares (4.7 acres) with a reiterated cost of €2.9 million or €2.9 per Watt despite a prior report mentioning a €3.5 million project cost. The project is supposed to be brought on grid by the end of November 2008 supplying about 400 homes with electricity.

After the ceremony, Erik Oldekop, Managing Director, Nanosolar International, said about 7000 solar modules will be required by the 1 MW project. This tidbit implies each module delivers about 142.9 Watts presumably at STC (Standard Test Conditions).

Next in June 2008, “WIRTSCHAFT: Sonnenmodul-Hersteller will expandieren, Stadt- und Kreisoberhaupt besuchen das Unternehmen Nanosolar” by Elinor Wenke reported on a visit by Luckenwalde town and Teltow-Fläming county officials to the Nanosolar GmbH production facility.

On production capacity, the first 100 MW is completed, while an additional 300 MW of capacity is supposed to be built out and in operation by yearend 2008. These capacity figures correlate to Nanosolar’s claims of accelerating production expansion to 620 MW at Nanosolar GmbH noting the help of 50% capex (capital expenditure) subsides from the German Federal and Brandenburg state governments. Nanosolar employs about 30 people altogether and expects to increase employment to the 50 to 70 person range in concert with the capacity ramp.

Nanosolar’s production line is a model of full automation with robots handling the processing steps for two (2) square meter glass plates used in the finished solar modules. At the time of the visit, the solar cells (produced in San Jose) and even the glass were shipped to the plant from the United States. Nanosolar GmbH Managing Director Olaf Dany said Nanosolar is in discussions with German firms to source the glass.

Knowing the solar module power rating of 142.9 Watts and the two (2) square meter size, the implied Nanosolar Utility Panel module efficiency is about 14%, confirming Nanosolar Blog claims in the post, "Nanosolar Achieves 1GW CIGS Deposition Throughput", =assuming= the various figures and information reported by the Märkische Allgemeine and stated by Nanosolar are correct. I have no reason to suspect they are not accurate.

GP Correction: As a reader pointed out, my efficiency calculation was wrong. Oops!
η = 142.9W / ((1000W/m^2)(2m^2)) = 7.15% conversion efficiency

Labels:

Saturday, December 22, 2007

Bah Humbug! eBay cancels Nanosolar Solar Panel Auction

due to the promised charitable use of the proceeds

In the Nanosolar Blog entry eBay cancels our Panel #2 auction — due to charitable angle, Nanosolar Inc. CEO Martin Roscheisen explains the ironic legal story.

In conclusion, Mr. Roscheisen said:

In other words, Panel #2 will stay at Nanosolar for now; thank you to everyone participating in our auction (any complaints about eBay directly to eBay please); and most importantly: HAPPY HOLIDAYS.

I first noticed this yesterday evening when the eBay Inc. (NASDAQ:EBAY) "bug" I set up to track the auction broke. Bummer, I found watching the auction an interesting holiday distraction.

Labels:

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Nanosolar Utility Panel #2 eBay Auction Update

Mind your Terms and Conditions
Solar panel to be held in escrow until June 1, 2009!

The Nanosolar Utility Panel #2 has been bid up on eBay from a Starting Price of US $0.99 to a post time high Bid of $10,700.00! Thirty-eight (38) bidders have made eighty-six (86) total bids to reach this point. Here is the Bid History.

In the description section, Nanosolar, Inc. said (Ed: bold added):

This solar panel is currently in Seller’s possession but it will be held in escrow until 6/1/2009 before local pick-up by the winning bidder (or shipment at cost to the winning bidder). Prior to delivery, the winning bidder agrees to sign an agreement with Seller prohibiting any reverse engineering of the solar panel or its components after the bidder receives the solar panel.

While the Wattage rating of the Nanosolar module is unknown, it is a safe bet this module is priced at over $50 (perhaps $100+?) per Watt at this point. Nice gross margin!

Nanosolar reserves the right to notify bidders and cancel this auction at anytime for any reason, but the PROCEEDS OF THIS AUCTION WILL BE USED FOR CHARITABLE CAUSE.

Labels:

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

Nanosolar solar modules shipping!

Nanosolar Utility Panel(TM) #2 can be purchased by the highest bidder on eBay.

NANOSOLAR-INC.-PANELS
Nanosolar module array under construction behind the Nanosolar GmbH building in Luckenwalde, Germany. Source: Nanosolar, Inc.

Nanosolar, Inc. made a series of reports that started here with the post, In Search of Nanosolar GmbH, official with the press release Nanosolar Shipping for Megawatt Municipal Power Plant, but the real news is in the Nanosolar Blog with the post permalink Nanosolar Ships First Panels.

Per Nanosolar Chief Executive Officer Martin Roscheisen:

Today we are announcing that we have begun shipping panels for freefield deployment in Eastern Germany and that the first Megawatt of our panels will go into a power plant installation there.

This is the same €2.8 Million reference solar farm project I uncovered during my Nanosolar research and was first reported in the October 13, 2007, article Von der Abfallhalde zur Solaranlage, CDU-Politiker besichtigen Mülldeponie, by Elinor Wenke. Nanosolar partnered with Beck Energy GmbH to win this project with an initial size of 1MWp (MegaWatt-peak) located at a retired landfill in Luckenwalde, Germany.

Mr. Roscheisen goes on to enumerate the disposition of the first three official shipping commercial modules (aka panels):

Panel #1 will remain at Nanosolar for exhibit.
Panel #2 can be purchased by you in an auction on eBay starting today.
Panel #3 has been donated to the Tech Museum in San Jose.

[These are obviously not the first three we ever produced – we have produced loads for testing – but these are the first three of what we consider our commercial panels.]

nansolarebae_1
Nanosolar module photo from the eBay auction.
Source: Nanosolar, Inc.

At first check, Nanosolar Utility Panel #2 had a highest bit of $810 USD. I wonder how much a competitor or intrepid enthusiast will be willing to pay to get their hands on one of these “babies”. A quick check of the Nanosolar Products page reveals this is the only technical datasheet available.

Mr. Roscheisen goes on to list the 5 top defining benefits of Nanosolar modules. This one attracted my attention as new news:

- the world’s highest-current thin-film solar panel – delivering five times the current of any other thin-film panel on the market today and thus simplifying system deployment;

GUNTHER Portfolio now stands at post number 193. Is it possible to reach the 200 post milestone by the end of 2007? The post run rate over the past few weeks will need to increase.

Labels:

Monday, December 10, 2007

In Search of Nanosolar GmbH

[Luckenwalde (Teltow-Fläming), Germany]

Checking on the status of the Nanosolar photovoltaic module production facility in Germany.
Nanosolar plans a €2.8 Million solar farm reference deployment on a nearby brownfield site.

After the 8. Forum Solarpraxis, I visited my cousin who lives south-southwest of Berlin near Luckenwalde, the home of Nanosolar’s module factory in Germany. I heard from a local source the deal was finalized and the location disclosed on June 12, 2007, per this notice from the Luckenwalde City Hall, Nanosolar übernimmt Stucki-Halle (Nanosolar takes over Stucki Factory), and in the regional newspaper, Zuschlag für Nanosolar, Neue Produktion in der Stucki-Halle (New production in the Stucki Factory).

At first, I proceeded to the end of Frankenfelder Strasse instead of driving down Frankenfelder Chaussee, and I found a small construction site located at a junk yard of sorts on a hill top. Such a small construction site couldn’t possibly be Nanosolar GmbH? No, but located in the Internet Dead Zone without an AirCard, I wasn’t able to double check the address. Navigating by nose, I recognized a familiar view from the direction of the Biotechnology Park Luckenwalde. It was the back of the Nanosolar GmbH module production facility.

Here are a few photos of the Nanosolar GmbH facility on the Sunday afternoon of my search. The Nanosolar signs were unobtrusive so it took a bit before I realized I had found it, and cars were absent from the parking lot. I apologize for the camera’s incorrect white balance setting resulting in the bluish tinge.

Well, reviewing the Nanosolar Blog alone, it is clear the company’s current primary focus is ramping CIGS (copper indium gallium diselenide) solar cell and module production at their San Jose facility.

In response to a press query and teaser photo taken during my Nanosolar GmbH “visit”, Nanosolar Chief Executive Officer Martin Roscheisen said:

Only preparatory work has been going on in Luckenwalde so far. The 24x6 panel line we operate in California has served all of our initial panel-assembly needs. Our German site is geared towards multi-100MW panel-assembly volume through a fully-automated line that is currently being developed by three tooling partners of ours. Our partners are on track to deliver this line as per our schedule. So there's going to be a lot of things happening in Luckenwalde very immediately!

Per the October 2007 Photon International article by Garrett Hering, Nanosolar to start »unbalanced« CIGS production at 430 MW plant by year-end:

Roscheisen would only say that Nanosolar expects to have an “unbalanced” production capacity by year-end, with some process steps at 100 MW and others already in the gigawatt range, and that the company is “sold out for 2008” at an unspecified level.

“Ours are sufficient to develop panels that are about 10-percent more efficient than First Solar’s,” claims Roscheisen. “The key thing,” he adds, “is that the quality of our CIGS coatings is indistinguishable from ones deposited with far more expensive vacuum machinery.”

About one week later, I visited the Nanosolar, Inc., location in San Jose on a Saturday afternoon. By contrast, there were about 20 cars in the parking lot.

Again, Nanosolar investor’s should be pleased the company isn’t wasting their money on fancy signage.

During my research, I uncovered this October 13, 2007, article in the Märkische Allgemeine, Von der Abfallhalde zur Solaranlage, CDU-Politiker besichtigen Mülldeponie, by Elinor Wenke. If my understanding is correct, Nanosolar is developing a large €2.8 Million reference solar farm project on a retired landfill site in 2008. This site is a few hundred meters down the road from Nanosolar GmbH, and the project is purported to be the first of its kind in the German state of Brandenburg.

The 50 production jobs enabled by Nanosolar GmbH are welcome in Luckenwalde where the unemployment rate touched a low of 15.2 percent for the first time since after the Wall fell. This August 2007 article, Quote bleibt bei 15,2 Prozent, 5274 Arbeitslose im Juli in der Region, by Uta Franke, indicates Nanosolar began hiring 11 employees for a job training program with production beginning in January 2008.

Mr. Roscheisen and the Nanosolar Team remember the balance and are in the process of bringing up module production at Nanosolar GmbH in the first quarter of 2008. Not every In Search of post will discover another AE Polysilicon situation.

Labels:

Monday, June 11, 2007

Solar Light Flashes: June 11, 2007

Quick Photovoltaic News Tidbits

I decided to revive the Light Flashes from last September and prefix Solar to satisfy the search engines. Solar Light Flashes will provide an ad hoc channel for the various factoids and observation pairs I stumble upon during my research for posts. Most of these factoids do not justify a complete post; combined I expect them to be informative.

This post is arranged in alphabetical order, and the company name or topic links back to my last significant related post.

Blue Square Energy (BSE):
BSE has been busy rounding out the team by hiring a CFO, Janis Studer Joins Blue Square Energy as Chief Financial Officer. And president and CEO Jeffrey Barnett was the presenter for Blue Square Energy to Present at the Jefferies 3rd Annual Global Clean Technology Conference although his presentation was not webcast. These moves would seem to indicate preparation for raising private equity capital or for an IPO.

GreenVolts:
GreenVolts launched a new home landing page in conjunction with the Business 2.0 Magazine article, Big Solar's day in the sun by Todd Woody. This article generated a maelstrom of search hits on the Blog looking for background on GreenVolts.

Moser Baer Photo Voltaic Limited (MBPV):
MBPV announces commercial shipment of solar photovoltaic cells and claims firm customer orders and MoUs exceeding US$100 million. In addition, MBPV expects their photovoltaic solar cells to have conversion efficiencies up to 15.5%. I guess that means at least one cell has achieved this conversion efficiency?

Nanosolar:
In Nanosolar loses chief scientist, Michael Kanellos blogs that Chris Eberspacher has left the firm. Does this mean there are problems with Nanosolar’s technology, disagreements with Nanosolar CEO Martin Roscheisen, or a transition from research and development to mass production and operations? Per Mr. Roscheisen:

Chris decided to leave, basically realizing that we now have a ton of really talented and passionate engineers on our team who know their respective areas so well that there's really not much for Chris to contribute. We remain on friendly terms with Chris and appreciate his pioneering a lot of the early science in CIGS.

NJCEP:
The NEW Market Managers have cranked out updated CORE Queue > 10kw June 7, 2007 (greater than 10kW) and CORE Queue <= 10kw June 8, 2007 (less than or equal to 10kW) almost every month. Debuting for the first time is the Public Non K-12 Schools CORE Queue May 31, 2007.

Solarvalue:
After five trilingual posts in NEWS FROM RUSE - THE BLOG (Deutsch, Slovensko), John Mott hasn’t updated the Blog since April 30, 2007. I guess John is too busy preparing TDR Ruse for Solar Grade Silicon production, but I am still jealous of his trilingual writing skills.

My accreditations have been approved and my travel arrangements are set for the Solar Promotion PV Industry Forum 2007 and Intersolar 2007. Thin films, Concentrating PhotoVoltaics (CPV), and Rural Electrification are the focus of the 3rd PV Industry Forum program this year in Freiburg im Breisgau.

Labels: , , , , ,

Sunday, May 06, 2007

Invest in Germany Spring 2007 Update

Industrial Investment Council (IIC) integration continues

Since I first mentioned the merger of the IIC with Invest in Germany (IiG) in the Christmas Eve Claudia Schiffer post, both organizations completed their merger on January 1, 2007, creating a common web landing page.

Two versions of the newsletter Spring 2007 FAST TRACK News from Germany – Photovoltaics are available for download; the earlier IIC version has a story about Novaled AG and Heliatek GmbH titled New Developments in Top Emitting OLEDs.

An updated Industry Overview: Photovoltaics is also available providing a one page summary of German photovoltaic production and new manufacturing ventures. Alas, the Photovoltaic Tooling overview has not been updated on the IIC website since December 2006.

In the Spring 2007 FAST TRACK newsletter, I learned Nanosolar, Inc. has secured their new solar panel manufacturing site in Luckenwalde, Germany, southwest of Berlin and a 45 minute drive to Schoenefeld Airport where the Berlin Brandenburg International (BBI) airport is being built. This was of personal interest to me because my aunt and cousin live just outside of Luckenwalde. Luckenwalde was part of East Germany and the local economy remains depressed with high unemployment. I can recommend a few good restaurants to the Nanosolar folks if they need some tips!

Labels: , ,

Friday, February 16, 2007

Towards Energy Autonomy (at Google)

New Politics for Renewable Energy

Dr. Hermann Scheer (Deutsch) elaborated on ideas from his latest book, Energy Autonomy: The economic, social, and technological case for renewable energy, to a sold out audience at Google Building 40 in Mountain View. The event was organized by German American Business Association of California, Inc. and the MIT Club of Northern California Clean Technology Program.

A full webcast of the event should go online tomorrow (or sooner?), so I wanted to get my video snipets of the Martin Roscheisen's introduction and the first four to five minutes of Dr. Scheer's talk posted ASAP.








For more video, check out Energy Autonomy - The Code of Survival, a media project based on Herman Scheer’s book. Experience the film (German only so far/ Deutsch) and discover and support the project (Deutsch).

Labels: , , ,